Dax McCarty is passionate about the Leagues Cup. No matter what anyone says about a competition that still hasn't gotten it right, the midfielder always enjoyed playing in the tournament. McCarty featured twice - once for Nashville and again for Atlanta United. And on both occasions, he embraced the energy that only the Mexico-U.S. rivalry can generate.
"When we played against Club America, when I was with Nashville two years ago, that was one of the craziest games I'd ever been involved in in my whole career," he told GOAL. "It was amazing. When we played against Monterrey in the semifinals, that was a real game of intensity, quality, with high level players. I mean, you name it, and Liga MX versus MLS, it does provide it."
It's a perspective that not everyone else shares. The Leagues Cup meant a lot to the Columbus Crew when they won it in 2024, but Liga MX clubs have expressed disdain for the competition. The competition has been revamped for the 2025 edition, increasing the number of MLS-Liga MX fixtures, and removing draws. Organizers hope it will give everything a little more zest.
"I think the Leagues Cup, it continues to evolve, and I'm hoping that this is the best version we see yet," he says.
And as hard to admit, it might just be Liga MX's time. The league has struggled in the competition in recent years - with MLS winning the last two iterations. But now, a new format should give the better teams a chance to show their quality.
"Club America is the slight favorite, even though they're playing their games on U.S. soil," he said. I think they've got a lot to prove. And I think that Liga MX team really wants to win this version. We've had two years in a row, an MLS team has won, and I think Liga MX's time."
McCarty discussed Leagues Cup, MLS All-Star Game, and why the league was right to suspend Lionel Messi in the latest edition of Mic'd Up, a recurring feature in which GOAL US taps into the perspective of broadcasters, analysts, and other pundits on the state of soccer in the U.S. and abroad.
NOTE: This interview has been lightly edited for brevity and clarity.